Why Ireland stands so firmly with Palestine : exploring Irish-Palestinian solidarity

Why Ireland stands so firmly with Palestine : exploring Irish-Palestinian solidarity

Ireland’s unwavering support for Palestinian rights has become one of the most distinctive aspects of modern European diplomacy. This solidarity extends far beyond governmental statements, deeply rooting itself in Irish society through historical parallels, shared experiences of oppression, and a profound understanding of colonial struggle.

Historical parallels driving Irish-Palestinian solidarity

The foundation of Irish solidarity with Palestine stems from centuries of British colonial rule that shaped Ireland’s national consciousness. From the 12th century until 1922, Ireland endured systematic oppression that mirrors many Palestinian experiences today. Professor Brendan Ciarán Browne from Trinity College Dublin explains how this colonial history creates natural empathy toward other colonized peoples.

The devastating Great Famine of 1845-1852, known as “An Gorta Mór,” killed over one million Irish people out of eight million inhabitants. This tragedy resulted from potato crop failure and Britain’s inadequate response, leaving indelible marks on Irish collective memory. Similar patterns of displacement, cultural suppression, and systematic marginalization connect Irish historical experience with contemporary Palestinian struggles.

A particularly striking connection involves the “Black and Tans” – British World War I veterans integrated into Irish policing from 1920. These forces, responsible for brutal civilian attacks in Ireland, were later deployed to British Mandate Palestine, where they implemented identical torture and policing methods. This direct transfer of oppressive tactics from Ireland to Palestine creates tangible historical links between both populations.

Historical Period Irish Experience Palestinian Parallel
Colonial Rule Duration 7 centuries (12th-20th century) Over 5 decades (1967-present)
Population Displacement Forced resettlements Refugee crisis since 1948
Cultural Suppression Language and customs targeted Heritage sites destruction

Arthur Balfour’s role exemplifies these interconnected histories. As former Chief Secretary for Ireland and later British Prime Minister, Balfour brutally suppressed Irish nationalism, earning the nickname “Bloody Balfour.” His 1917 Balfour Declaration supporting Jewish homeland establishment in Palestine demonstrates how British officials shaped both Irish and Palestinian destinies, often through oppressive policies.

Political recognition and diplomatic initiatives

Ireland’s official recognition of Palestinian statehood on May 28, 2024, alongside Norway and Spain, represents decades of consistent diplomatic support. However, this recognition follows a longer pattern of Irish advocacy for Palestinian rights dating back to the 1950s. Foreign Minister Frank Aiken made groundbreaking statements at UN General Assembly sessions, advocating for Palestinian refugee return rights in 1958 and demanding Israeli withdrawal to pre-1967 borders following the Six-Day War.

Ireland’s diplomatic approach demonstrates remarkable consistency across different governments. The country contributed to UNRWA budgets since the late 1950s and provided soldiers for UN observation groups in Lebanon. In 1974, Ireland became among the first European nations recognizing the Palestine Liberation Organization as Palestinian representatives, decades before many EU counterparts took similar positions.

Interestingly, Ireland established an Israeli embassy only in 1996, making it the last EU member to do so despite recognizing Israel de facto in 1949 and de jure in 1963. This delay partly reflected Catholic Ireland’s proximity to Vatican positions regarding Jerusalem’s internationalization, ensuring Christian access to holy sites in Israeli-occupied East Jerusalem.

Recent developments include Ireland’s threat to boycott Eurovision 2024 if Israel participated, with national broadcaster RTÉ stating participation would be inappropriate given ongoing civilian casualties in Gaza. Such positions demonstrate how Irish solidarity extends beyond traditional diplomatic channels into cultural and sporting spheres.

Civil society mobilization and grassroots support

Irish public opinion strongly supports Palestinian rights, with November 2023 polling showing 71% of respondents believing Palestinians live under Israeli apartheid system. The survey, conducted by Ireland Thinks for the Irish Anti-Apartheid Campaign for Palestine coalition, sampled 1,387 people with 2.7% margin of error, revealing broad-based solidarity transcending party lines.

Political party supporters show varying degrees of Palestinian solidarity :

  • Solidarity-People Before Profit : 100% agreement on apartheid characterization
  • Labour Party : 90% supporting Palestinian positions
  • Social Democrats : 86% backing Palestinian rights
  • Fianna Fáil : 71% agreeing with apartheid assessment
  • Fine Gael : 56% supporting Palestinian solidarity

The Irish Congress of Trade Unions became one of Europe’s first labor federations supporting the 2005 Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) campaign. This movement, launched by Palestinian civil society to pressure Israel regarding occupation and refugee return rights, generates significant controversy. While supporters characterize BDS as non-violent resistance, Israel condemns it as antisemitic, leading to legislative restrictions in over two dozen US states.

Civil society influence extends to financial sectors, with Ireland’s Central Bank withdrawing authorization for Israeli bond sales on European markets following grassroots campaigns. These bonds enable Israeli wartime fundraising during Gaza operations. Post-Brexit, Ireland managed this approval process for the entire EU, though Israel now seeks Luxembourg authorization transfer.

Contemporary challenges and future prospects

Despite widespread public support, some analysts argue Irish government responses remain primarily symbolic. Professor Brendan Ciarán Browne suggests genuine Palestinian solidarity comes from grassroots activists and citizen movements rather than official government initiatives. This dynamic creates tension between popular sentiment and diplomatic constraints.

Ireland faces significant economic pressures limiting its Palestinian advocacy. The United States represents Ireland’s largest export destination, with over 970 American companies employing 211,000 Irish workers – approximately 7.5% of the national workforce according to US Chamber of Commerce data. These deep economic ties with Israel’s primary ally create diplomatic limitations on Irish policy options.

Northern Ireland presents a contrasting landscape reflecting sectarian divisions. Catholic republicans supporting Irish reunification typically back Palestinian causes, while Protestant unionists express solidarity with Israel. This division demonstrates how historical conflicts shape contemporary international solidarity patterns within Ireland itself.

Ireland’s peace process experience through the 1998 Good Friday Agreement provides valuable insights for Middle Eastern conflict resolution. The successful transformation from armed conflict to democratic governance offers potential models for Palestinian-Israeli negotiations, with Irish diplomats frequently offering mediation services based on their conflict resolution expertise.

Clara Byrne
Scroll to Top